import scala.reflect.macros.BlackboxContext import language.experimental.macros case class C[T](t: String) object C { implicit def foo[T]: C[T] = macro Macros.impl[T] } object Macros { def impl[T](c: BlackboxContext)(ttag: c.WeakTypeTag[T]) = { import c.universe._ val ttag0 = ttag; { // When we're expanding implicitly[C[Nothing]], the type inferencer will see // that foo[T] returns C[T] and that we request an implicit of type C[Nothing]. // // Then the type inferencer will try to match C[T] against C[Nothing] and infer everything it can infer // from that match, but not more (e.g. if we were returning Iso[T, U] and the type we were looking at was Iso[Foo, L], // we wouldn't want U to be auto-inferred to Nothing, as it usually happens with normal methods, // but would rather want it to remain unknown, so that our macro could take a stab at inferring it: // see the comments in this commit for more information). // // Equipped with common sense, in our case of C[T] and C[Nothing] we would expect T to be inferred as Nothing, and then we // would expect T in the corresponding macro invocation to be Nothing. Unfortunately it is not that simple. // // Internally the type inferencer uses Nothing as a dummy value, which stands for "don't know how to // infer this type parameter". In the Iso example, matching Iso[T, U] against Iso[Foo, L] would result in // T being inferred as Foo and U being inferred as Nothing (!!). Then the type inferencer will think: // "Aha! U ended up being Nothing. This means that I failed to infer it, // therefore the result of my work is: T -> Foo, U -> still unknown". // // That's all very good and works very well until Nothing is a genuine result of type inference, // as in our original example of inferring T in C[T] from C[Nothing]. In that case, the inferencer becomes confused // and here in the macro implementation we get weakTypeOf[T] equal to some dummy type carrying a type parameter // instead of Nothing. // // This eccentric behavior of the type inferencer is a long-standing problem in scalac, // so the best one can do for now until it's fixed is to work around, manually converting // suspicious T's into Nothings. Of course, this means that we would have to approximate, // because there's no way to know whether having T here stands for a failed attempt to infer Nothing // or for a failed attempt to infer anything, but at least we're in full control of making the best // of this sad situation. implicit def ttag: WeakTypeTag[T] = { val tpe = ttag0.tpe val sym = tpe.typeSymbol.asType if (sym.isParameter && !sym.isSkolem) TypeTag.Nothing.asInstanceOf[TypeTag[T]] else ttag0 } reify(C[T](c.Expr[String](Literal(Constant(weakTypeOf[T].toString))).splice)) } } }